When it comes to selling a home on Long Island, speed can make all the difference. Whether you’re relocating, handling an inherited property, or facing financial pressures, certain towns consistently see faster sales due to high demand, desirable locations, and strong buyer competition. Based on market data, buyer trends, and local demand, here are the Top 5 Long Island towns where homes tend to sell quickly, along with the hot zip codes you should know.
1. Hicksville (11801 – Nassau County)
Hicksville has long been considered one of Nassau County’s most desirable and dynamic real estate markets. Conveniently located in the heart of Long Island, Hicksville offers homeowners and buyers the perfect balance of suburban living and commuter accessibility.
One of the town’s biggest draws is the Hicksville Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) station, which is one of the busiest hubs on the Island. From Hicksville, commuters can reach Penn Station or Grand Central Madison in Manhattan in under an hour, making it ideal for professionals who work in the city but want more space and affordability than New York City living can provide.
In addition to rail service, Hicksville provides quick access to major highways like the Long Island Expressway (I-495), Northern State Parkway, and Wantagh Parkway, connecting residents easily to all parts of Long Island and beyond.
Families are also attracted to Hicksville for its reputable schools, plentiful parks, and growing variety of dining and shopping options. Broadway Mall, along with nearby retail centers, offers convenience, while walkable neighborhoods add to the community’s appeal.
From an investment perspective, Hicksville offers a range of housing styles, including Cape Cods, ranches, colonials, and split-level homes. Inventory is usually limited, and competitively priced homes in the 11801 zip code often receive multiple offers within days of hitting the market.
2. Levittown (11756 – Nassau County)
Levittown holds a special place in American history as the birthplace of the modern suburb. Built after World War II to provide affordable housing for returning veterans and their families, Levittown has grown into one of the most recognizable and in-demand communities on Long Island. Today, it continues to thrive as a hot seller’s market, where homes rarely stay on the market for long.
What makes Levittown so attractive to buyers is its combination of affordability, convenience, and family-friendly appeal. Compared to nearby Nassau County towns like East Meadow or Wantagh, Levittown homes are often more budget-friendly while still offering access to strong schools, well-kept neighborhoods, and plenty of community amenities.
Levittown is known for its classic Cape Cods and ranch-style homes, many of which have been updated or expanded over the years. For buyers, these properties represent a chance to get into the Long Island market at a reasonable price point. For sellers, especially longtime owners or estates, demand from first-time buyers and young families keeps competition strong.
The community offers excellent recreational opportunities, including pools, parks, playgrounds, and sports fields, making it ideal for families who value outdoor activities. Its central location in Nassau County also provides quick access to major highways like the Wantagh Parkway and Hempstead Turnpike, plus shopping centers and restaurants, all of which add to its desirability.
In Levittown’s 11756 zip code, it’s not uncommon for properly priced homes to receive multiple offers shortly after hitting the market. As a result, sellers often benefit from faster closings and competitive bidding.
3. Sayville (11782 – Suffolk County)
Sayville is often described as one of Long Island’s hidden gems on the South Shore. Known for its historic charm, vibrant waterfront lifestyle, and community spirit, Sayville attracts buyers who want the feel of coastal living without the premium price tags of the Hamptons. This demand makes it one of the quicker-moving real estate markets in Suffolk County.
One of the town’s biggest draws is its walkable, charming downtown area, lined with boutique shops, family-owned restaurants, and cafés. Buyers are often captivated by Sayville’s “Main Street feel”, which combines small-town character with modern convenience.
Waterfront access also adds to the appeal. Located along the Great South Bay, Sayville offers boating, fishing, and beach opportunities, as well as ferry service to Fire Island, a top summer destination. For many New York City transplants or Long Island locals seeking a more relaxed pace of life, Sayville delivers an ideal blend of seaside charm and accessibility.
Families are attracted to the Sayville School District, which has a strong reputation and adds significant value to the area’s housing market. Meanwhile, the presence of parks, marinas, and community events throughout the year makes Sayville not only a place to live, but a lifestyle choice.
From a real estate standpoint, the 11782 zip code features a mix of historic Victorian-style homes, classic colonials, ranches, and even modern builds. Waterfront and waterview properties sell especially fast, but even inland homes tend to move quickly thanks to limited inventory and high demand.
For sellers, Sayville’s market often favors those looking to downsize or sell inherited homes, as demand from buyers—ranging from young families to retirees—is consistently strong.
4. Commack (11725 – Suffolk County)
Commack is one of Suffolk County’s most desirable North Shore communities, offering residents a perfect balance of suburban comfort, excellent schools, and commuter convenience. Homes here consistently sell quickly due to limited inventory and steady buyer demand.
A major driver of Commack’s real estate market is the Commack School District, which is widely regarded as one of the strongest in Suffolk County. Families moving from other parts of Long Island often seek out this area specifically for its educational opportunities, making demand for single-family homes particularly high.
Commack also appeals to professionals thanks to its proximity to major highways, including the Long Island Expressway (I-495), Sunken Meadow Parkway, and Northern State Parkway. These connections make it a convenient hub for those commuting east toward business centers or west toward New York City.
The town features a variety of home styles, including large colonials, expanded ranches, split-levels, and custom builds, often on spacious lots. Buyers are drawn to the combination of generous square footage and suburban privacy, which can be harder to find in Nassau County at a comparable price.
Beyond schools and convenience, Commack offers a high quality of life with parks, shopping centers, and recreational opportunities nearby. Properties in the 11725 zip code often sell quickly, especially those in family-friendly neighborhoods with well-maintained homes and curb appeal.
For sellers, this market tends to favor families upgrading to larger homes, estates liquidating inherited properties, and homeowners relocating for work opportunities. Because buyer demand outpaces supply, homes that are priced correctly often generate strong interest within days of listing.
5. Massapequa (11758 – Nassau County)
Massapequa has long been one of Nassau County’s most sought-after communities, thanks to its unique blend of suburban convenience, waterfront living, and strong schools. With demand consistently outweighing supply, homes in Massapequa often sell quickly—sometimes within days of hitting the market.
One of the town’s most distinctive features is its waterfront lifestyle. Many neighborhoods sit along the South Shore’s canals and bays, offering direct access for boating, fishing, and other water activities. For buyers seeking a waterfront property without venturing to the Hamptons, Massapequa is a prime choice. Even homes just off the water tend to move quickly because of the area’s proximity to beaches and parks.
Massapequa is also known for its excellent school districts, including Massapequa School District and Plainedge School District, which consistently draw families from across Long Island. Combined with a variety of recreational amenities like John J. Burns Park, Massapequa Preserve, and nearby beaches, the town provides an attractive quality of life for residents of all ages.
The housing stock in the 11758 zip code includes a mix of expanded ranches, split-levels, capes, colonials, and custom new construction, many of which have been renovated or expanded over the years. Waterfront and waterview homes, in particular, are in extremely high demand and often receive multiple offers.
Buyers in Massapequa include both locals trading up to larger homes and city buyers relocating from Brooklyn or Queens for more space while maintaining reasonable access to New York City via the LIRR. Because of this demand, typical sellers include retirees looking to downsize, heirs selling inherited properties, and homeowners relocating for lifestyle or career reasons.